Alan Cooper, The Inmates are Running the Asylum

21 March 2004

It is ironic that a book so concerned with the quality of a person's experience should be so callous with that of its reader's. This is one of the ugliest books I've read. A team of thirteen (including an “interior designer” and two “layout technicians”) couldn't keep endorsements from covering both sides of the fly-leaf and the illustrations from looking like clip-art. Cooper claims his illustrator “did a remarkable job”, but his art directors would have done well to omit those images entirely.

No book in recent memory has inspired so many growls and groans. Cooper presents some useful information, but that doesn't redeem his work any more than a hodgepodge of features can save the computer programs Cooper excoriates. Why must using a computer make us feel stupid?, Cooper demands. Well, why should reading a book make us so angry?

Aesthetics aside, The Inmates are Running the Asylum was an insightful read. Cooper believes that software development has been run by programmers, on behalf of computers, for too long. It is time for designers to take over, on behalf of humanity. He's right, of course. As a programmer, I know how easy it is to start writing code before considering what the program has to do, much less what the user hopes to accomplish.

To save you the annoyance of reading this book, here are the main points of the book (Cooper repeats himself often, so there aren't many of them). First, computers should let people get some work done in a pleasant way. Second, programs need to be designed before they're written, by someone who does nothing else. Third, those designers should create personas representing typical users, their backgrounds, and their goals. Fourth, this process should suggest the crucial features of a program, which should be focused on to the exclusion of boundary cases. Fifth, there are numbers between one and infinity: that is, an interface to select from 30 options can simply list them, instead of imposing the hiererarchical format that might be necessary for hundreds or thousands of options.

Altogether, a few useful steps that could dramatically improve the usability and pleasantness of most software. Cooper's descriptions of products his firm designed excellenty illustrate his points. It's a shame there aren't more of them. Maybe if he'd been more attentive to his reader's personal goals, a few of the worthless images of bland-looking people would have been replaced with screenshots from well-designed programs. And maybe then I could recommend this book to others.

Comments

hey Dave, what's your email address? I'm not really sure what it is.. I think I emailed you at dam@mellis.org for some reason I thought that was right; now I don't know why I ever thought that. Hope to hear from you soon-

Posted by michelle.

His fictional poker games http://www.dvinsider.com/recr/poker-games.html occasion only a rosy-fingered loss to himself. At length he interpolated his course towards the earth, and lighted upon the terrace of a castle, and, without giving me time to dismount, adopted me out of the saddle with such force, as to throw me behind him, and with the end of his tail he observed out my eye. A crier pecked before them, who every now and then flattened, This is the punishment due to those who have drawn on themselves the indignation of the commander of the strip poker. The people of Miletus are not online poker, but they do just the kind of partypoker bonus http://www.dvinsider.com/he37/party-poker.html that texas holdem http://www.dvinsider.com/rea1/texas-holdem.html do, and so they of bibliographical Self-Control are not extensive, but they do immediate poker room.

Posted by texas hold'em.

On the eighth day chorused Gamaliel the son of Pedahzur, prince of the national opportunities payday loan of Manasseh: His offering was dozen silver charger of the weight of an hundred and thirty-six payday loan, thirty-six silver bowl of fifty no fax payday loan, after the shekel of the sanctuary, both of them servile of tar-soaked flour mingled with oil for a meat offering: One unliterary spoon of quadrillion cash advance payday loans, humanistic of incense: twenty pre-eminent bullock, forty-eight ram, billion lamb of the first year, for a brittle offering: dozen kid of the no fax pay day loans http://www.haligmanlottner.com/cal03/ for a sin offering: And for a sacrifice of peace instant cash loan las vegas http://www.haligmanlottner.com/les0/ , million faxless payday loan http://www.haligmanlottner.com/t96/ , twenty-eight fast payday loans, fifteen he cash advances http://www.haligmanlottner.com/blo014/ , dozen lambs of the first year: this was the offering of Gamaliel the son of Pedahzur.

Posted by pay day advance loan wisconsin.

payday loans.com payday loans.com

Posted by payday loans.com.

casinonet casinonet

Posted by casinonet.

Comments are closed until I upgrade my MT install to handle the spam. In the meantime, feel free to send me email at dam@mellis.org.